Right now I am writing what is
probably one of the hardest things I’ve ever written. You see, for some stupid
reason I wrote the death of a child into one of the chapters of my current work-in-progress
[WIP.] The death is very significant to the overall plot so I can’t write it
out. Removing it would be like taking the dead man out of Dead Man’s Cell
Phone. Needless to say, I cannot retract it.
And I don’t want to. Writing can be
hard and that’s what makes for great writing. As much as I’d like them to be,
themes, scenes and plots can’t always be happy-rosy. They can be jarring, they
can be gritty, and they can be downright upsetting to both write and read.
I always talk about balance—about
learning to accept the bad with the good. I’m certainly learning to accept the
bad on this one. I’m not ashamed to admit that this particular piece caused me
to shed a few tears throughout its many versions. Still, I am going to write the
bad and I’m going to give it everything I have. This is definitely one of the
defining moments in my life as a writer.
However. I am so hell-bent on getting this moment perfect that I can’t seem to get it right. I have re-written this piece three times now and my words still do not jive with my intent. No matter what I do with it I am not satisfied. It is as if the universe is intentionally trying to stump me to teach me some sort of lesson.
“Don’t
write about children dying,” Maybe?
Here’s how it’s gone: I dropped a
serious drama bomb with the first draft. It was too over-the-top. I rode the
drama-llama out of town with the second. It was far too sterile for such an
emotional chapter. The third draft was smack dab in the middle—dramalicious
without being overly dramatic.
And I just deleted it.
Seriously. It’s gone. Adios. Aloha.
Sayoonara. Bai bai. With a single drag and drop into my Mac’s trash-bin I
deleted four hours of hard work.
And—nope. There is no back-up copy. I
did not e.mail it to myself. Nor did I print out a copy to place in my big fat WIP
folder. There aren’t any written-on receipts stuffed into bag of notes. The
words are—plain and simple—gone. That is that.
Am I bothered? Actually, not really.
Sure, I did lose around 7-8k words and approximately 10 hours of work between
the three versions, but something about each one of them felt wrong. They
weren’t what I wanted them to be. There was no real “Eureka!” moment while
writing any one of them. That is why I do not much mind repeating my
efforts—again.
Not everything is perfect the first
time around. In fact, few things are. Yes, there are ‘naturally gifted’
writers—and you may be one of them—but naturally talented baseball players
still frequent the batting cages, don’t they?
There will be thoughts that take time and a little bit of elbow grease to
blossom. They won’t immediately bloom into the flower you want them to be.
That’s what happened in my case. My brain needed a few revisions before the
right story clearly developed and it was set on what it wanted to do. Then the
good stuff came.
Sad, sure—but good.
I know that this is only a rough draft
and that I will come to revisit it during the complete-work rewrites, but what
it did for me was instrumental: it got me going in the right direction. This
way, when I come back to it, I will not be asking myself why it is I chose to
write what I did. As well, I will not be completely confusing both myself and
the reader with this moment.
It is important to remember that there
are times when you have to take what you’ve written and throw it out of the
proverbial window—maybe not to the extent that I did this week, but to some
extent, at least. Difficult, I know—but the act of starting again is one you’ll
need to partake in if you want to improve. Some may see it as wasting time. I
see it as creating a better ‘next time.’ So, instead of looking at deleting as
“lost time and effort,” look at it as “gained quality and satisfaction.”
At any rate, try not to grow too attached to your words. Sometimes, deleting
them is better.
—R
Hey Randi,
ReplyDeleteNice words there. Something similar once happened to me. I lost a good portion of my work. I didn't deal with it nearly as well as you have, so kudos to you. :)
As for writing about children dying, you said it yourself. Writing should be challenging. Not easy. If you feel you need to write this, then no matter how uncomfortable it makes you, my two cents say: be careful, but be true.
Thanks for the read,
G.
Hey-thanks, Dany! I appreciate the comment. And thanks for the kudos :) I'll admit it was not easy the first time around, but it got easier as my finger warmed up to the delete key ;)
DeleteThanks again!
True words, here. There's a difference between writing being hard but worth it, and writing being so difficult that you realise it's fighting against you - and needs to be chucked.
ReplyDeleteThanks, SP! Glad you agree--there's a recycle bin for a reason! ;) Thanks for the comment!
DeleteHi Randi
ReplyDeleteGreat post. Sometimes the things that are the hardest and most challenging to write (such as a death) are the ones that ring the truest with the reader. It is often worth all that emotional input that you put into it.
In the end it definitely can be worth it, I agree. Getting to the end is sometimes the hard part ;) Thanks for the comment!!
DeleteOne of my favorite sayings when it comes to writing is "murder your darlings" and it looks like that applies on more than one level to this post!
ReplyDeleteI enjoy rewrites, because I feel like the hardest work is done and the finish line is in sight (or around the corner, at least), but choosing what to cut and what to keep can be agonizing. Agonizing, but so very necessary. Coming to terms with that is the most important step though, and you've long since taken it! That's more than a lot of writers can say.
"Murder your darlings," eh? I like that one--am going to have to hold on to it! And yes--rewrites really are fantastic things. Frustrating (extremely frustrating) at some points, yes, but in the end they're for the best.
DeleteAND PS! Thanks for the Re-tweet, JW! You truly are the best of the best!!!
I gasped when I saw you deleted all that work but I am glad you see it positively :) & while it sounds like a challenging scene I am sure it is worth it. I for example thought the scene in the hunger games where Rue died was one of the most touching/deepest moments for me in the book.
ReplyDeleteYeah-- I have to say that scene really did shake me up. I hope I can pull this off as being sorry without making anyone upset in the wrong way.
DeleteStill glad I deleted it...things feel much better this way! Thanks for the comment!!!
Hat tip to you, Randi_lee, in appreciation/respect for your knack for always finding the silver-lining so to speak. Conversely, if I had invested that many words and time, not sure if I could regroup with such steadfast composure and a winning attitude to boot. Wishing you continued success as you fine tune your work.
ReplyDeleteBringing light to that age old adage "practice makes perfect", You said: "naturally talented baseball players still frequent the batting cages, don’t they?" Every baseball manager around the major league would appreciate your good sense/smarts.
Thanks so much, Al! Trust me, I wasn't always this composed. It took many zen moments and learning to say, "No, Randi, this is not the best you can do" (a stab to any ego!) before I started following the philosophy that sometimes lost time makes greater product.
DeleteI like the way you connect what I say to the real world...makes me think I should publish a quote book or something, a ha ha! Anyway, take care, Al-- and, as always, thanks for stopping by.
Just popping by from the IWSG. I know how it feels to kill off a character--I personally felt downright evil, but it was supposed to be an evil scene, and it was a key moment in the plot. Good on you for re-working your scene and not getting married to the words. Sometimes things have to be cut to make the scene work. Good luck!
ReplyDeleteThanks so much for stopping by, Siobhan! And, yes--as hard as it can be some words are just meant to be deleted! Thanks again for stopping by and for commenting :)
ReplyDeleteSounds tough! I've been through edits of edits of re-writes of rough drafts before. I find it so often happens with the opening chapter of things! I hope it works out for you in the end - I admire people who do what they're "not meant to do", because it's the right thing for their book.
ReplyDelete